Share
Email This Page
add comment

Shirley Sherrod Says She Will Sue Andrew Breitbart

Print
Thursday, 29 July 2010 17:29
Ousted Agriculture Department employee Shirley Sherrod listens during a panel discussion at the National Association of Black Journalists, 07/29/10. (photo: Gregory Bull/AP)

Ousted Agriculture Department employee Shirley Sherrod listens during a panel discussion at the National Association of Black Journalists, 07/29/10. (photo: Gregory Bull/AP)

 

 

The ousted USDA worker threatens legal action for a video edited to make her look racist.

hirley Sherrod, the US Department of Agriculture employee who was ousted after Andrew Breitbart released a video selectively edited to make it appear as if she had made racist remarks, has announced that she will sue the conservative blogger.

According to the Associated Press, Sherrod told the National Association of Black Journalists convention in San Diego today that she intends to take legal action. Earlier this month Breitbart released a video clip of Sherrod making a speech at an NAACP banquet in March of this year. The portion of the speech posted to YouTube showed Sherrod telling the crowd that in 1986 she had not helped a white farmer with financial difficulties as she might have helped a black one, purely because of his race. She was swiftly asked to resign by Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack, and condemned on Fox News and by the NAACP. Breitbart, and many others on the right, used the clip to imply that the NAACP, which often points out that elements of the Tea Party movement are racist, was itself prejudiced against white people.

However, when the full, unedited video emerged it showed that Sherrod used the tale as a parable for equal rights. She received phone apologies from Vilsack and President Obama and has been offered a new job with the USDA (which she is considering).

Breitbart remains unrepentant, and argues that the video still shows racism in the NAACP. He has not apologized. If Sherrod follows through on her threat to sue, it will reignite a debate on race that looked, as the president discussed it today on the talk show The View, as if it might be dying down.

A call to Breitbart was not immediately returned.

 

Open Article On Originating Site

 

Comments  

 
+15 # goodsensecynic 2010-07-29 20:34
The trouble with most issues is that they die down, to be replaced with new ones as the cycle of disinfotainment continues to entertain but not to enlighten us, much less to take steps to improve our society by opposing the wrongs upon which it seems to depend.

Perhaps if the crimes of the authorities, the irresponsibilit y of the "fourth estate" and the witless bigotry of as much as 50% of the electorate could be held up for more than the time it takes to go to a commercial, we could promote change we can accomplish, not just "believe in."
 
 
+23 # Guest 2010-07-29 21:57
Breitbart is NOT "fourth estate!" He wouldn't know journalism if he were plunked down in a newsroom and told to report on something happening right before his eyes. He's a hatcheteer. The tape fragment he used was NOT "edited" -- it was contrived. Ditto his hatchet-job on ACORN. Fox is not a news channel, it's a propaganda outlet -- it's slanted so far that it's upside down. To take them at their "creative" word produces political mayhem, as committed by Vilsack & his mouthpiece, the one who called Sherrod three times to demand her resignation by text, right in the middle of highway traffic. Of course, the fact that some people fall for this garbage, and vote by it, is the American tragedy.
 
 
0 # Guest 2010-07-30 22:30
AMEN
 
 
+17 # Guest 2010-07-29 22:20
Creeps like Breitbart should not be allowed to malign people like he did Mrs. Sharrod. I hope he gets slapped with a fat fine. Hit him where it hurts.

He doesn't give damn that he hurts people's reputations or feelings. He needs to understand that people will fight back.
 
 
+5 # Guest 2010-07-30 13:46
A fine is meaningless. The rabid right wingers will merely pony up the money for him and close ranks around him. The jackass needs to do time. Only then can you be sure he pays the penalty himself. Of course a nice settlement for Mrs. Sharrod wouldn't hurt either.
 
 
+16 # Guest 2010-07-29 23:22
Can anyone explain to me why, in all the so-called reporting on the Sherrod affair that I've heard on National Public Radio this past week, the reporters fall all over themselves NOT to mention the name "Andrew Breitbart?" Fox News sure doesn't shy away from naming names — wrong or otherwise. I'm not suggesting that NPR or any other news outlet spread disinformation. Fox News does a perfect job of that all by themselves. A lot of people were responsible for making this bad situation worse. But Andrew Breitbart started the mess, and everyone in this country should be aware of his dirty tricks, so he can't pull the wool over people's eyes again. I'm glad that Shirley Sherrod is taking him to task. And congratulations to those few news outlets with the cojones to call the culprit by name.
 
 
+18 # Guest 2010-07-29 23:36
I wish her all the very best. Sue the bastard!
 
 
+19 # Guest 2010-07-29 23:55
I hope she sues the pants off of that liar! I am still angry with John Kerry for not taking those Swift Boat Repubaliars to Court! In this day and age you cannot play by Marquis of Queensbury Rules. Maybe those nut-cases will think twice before saying that their lies are the truth, when they lose a million dollars for trying to steal someone's good name! Good for Sherrod; she's got guts.
 
 
+5 # Guest 2010-07-30 00:44
Shame on the NAACP and shame on the President! They should have looked a bit harder to find the truth.

First the so-called mainstream press legitimized Fox News by answering their disinfotainment (nice term) by covering it 'as news.' That my friends, was their intent.

Second, Obama does not appear to be tiring from the strategy "kiss the Grand Ole' White-Man's Party of No" to show that he is 'reaching out'. As a result, the propagandist-geniuses have scored a major victory: Obama now looks like an Uncle Tom, subservient to Republicans, and pulling back on what could have been successful political moves in support of working people. He is out-Mondaling Mondale in a bid to out-Republicanizing the GOP. BTW, it doesn't work.

Obama this week falls prey to the hate speech and division that his presidential campaign rose above. He legitimizes the propaganda on 'illegals' and attempts to look tougher than Dick Cheney with a Bionic Heart.

Strike three Obama!
 
 
+12 # Guest 2010-07-30 00:49
I hope she does sue this guy, because it's not just about racism....it's about LYING and contorting the truth with casual abandon. And that is something that has become way too commonplace, and not just on "FIXED" News...er, I meant FOX News. I believe it was Lenin who is attributed with saying "a lie told often enough, becomes truth". Too few bloviators get called to account, thus their words gain credibility and power with every repetition.
 
 
+3 # Guest 2010-07-30 04:14
It was Goebbels who said that, not Lenin.
 
 
+9 # Guest 2010-07-30 03:06
Go Shirley, go! Take a leaf out of the Southern Poverty Law Center's book & sue him for damages so great that he'll be forced to take his website down & won't be able to even take a leak without permission.
 
 
+8 # Guest 2010-07-30 04:21
Can I/we contribute $$ toward her legal fees? It might not properly be called a "defense fund", but it essentially it and this woman needs and deserves our defending. She should have been reinstated immediately. But then again, she never should have been fired. My God, she is exactly the kind of person we need working in our government. UP WITH SHIRLEY!
 
 
+10 # Guest 2010-07-30 04:55
Excellent News! And I hope Sherrod adds FN as a co-conspirator!
 
 
+5 # Guest 2010-07-30 07:25
@cynibunny said "Shame on the NAACP and shame on the President! They should have looked a bit harder to find the truth."

If Vilsack was calling for her resignation from his car when he heard some account of Brietbart's lying, butchered tape, seems to me there was no time to involve President Obama. First I recall of Obama's involvement, he was on the phone countermanding Vilsack. That seems like backing up Sherrod.

As for delaying a response long enough to find the facts, that just seems like good judgement to me. It should draw kudos not brickbats.

I won't claim to have followed this whole affair closely, though I admire the hell out of Sherrod for fighting back. I wish more Democrats in power had that much spine.
 
 
+1 # Guest 2010-07-30 11:55
The sad facts are, with the conservative right wing five Supreme Courts Five, these liars can just laugh at justice!

Until those five SCJ's are sitting their big fat corporate bought behinds, only the corrupted will have their day in court.

We need more than just sue those sorry bastards, we need to remove them before the country slips into the sewers!
 
 
+1 # Guest 2010-07-30 14:39
It is Sherrod's right to sue Brietbart or others if she was hurt by these lies.
The public solution is to call the people who decide to run such a story to account. Ignore Brietbart because anything you say about him makes him bigger than he is-- he is really a small man acting out an angry, spiteful agenda, with little regard for truth-- go after the networks such as Fox that give him legitimacy. This is the real issue, after all. Such an investigation must be very pointed. Shine the spotlight on those who made the decision to run this particular story-- the precise people by name and background, as well as the policy wonks of the network who desire such content, and the monetary influences/political leanings that underlie it. The New York Times or CNN or anyone else who prepensely publicizes such an example of distorted content should also be scrutinized, just as the decision of the Obama administration to act so quickly is also a legitimate topic.
 
 
0 # Guest 2010-07-30 19:44
BOSS SHOULD BE FIRED "asked to resign by Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack"? - on order from White House - who ordered it?
THIS PERSON - bad decision maker should be fired.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.