Email This Page
add comment
read more of todays top articles

Excerpt: "A man ran past in the street trying to catch a galloping black thoroughbred stallion, one of Uday Hussein’s private herd, that had been set free from the adjacent Olympic sports grounds. Soon afterward a thundering procession of Marines in tanks rolled by. I noted down the names they had spray-painted on the barrels of their guns: 'Assassin,' 'Carnage,' 'Cold Steel,' 'Crazy Train,' 'Rebel,' and 'Got Oil?'"

A soldier stands guard outside a Iraqi brick factory, 05/05/05. (photo: Staff Sgt. Russell Klika/U.S. Army)
A soldier stands guard outside a Iraqi brick factory, 05/05/05. (photo: Staff Sgt. Russell Klika/U.S. Army)

 

Comments  

 
+7 # Guest 2010-09-01 21:31
In response to Diamondback at 11:29

"None-the-less, in the end, whether under the thumb of a brutal dictator or free floating in chaos, one can never escape the yolk of personal responsibility."

None-the-less, we were the ones holding the guns, with tanks in the street, having hours before destroyed the status quo power and thus created the power vacuum. Thus according to your viewpoint, we are the ones who shirked our responsibility to stop the chaos, looting, destruction. We are the ones who (tried) to escape, to use your phrase, "the yolk of personal responsibility".
 
 
+9 # Guest 2010-09-01 22:58
The point of this, was?
Can anyone give me an honest answer?
Greed?
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-09-01 23:37
Diamondback - I believe General Shinseki would have done a better job just as his predecessors did in Germany and Japan after WWII. But then 'stuff happens.'
 
 
+15 # Guest 2010-09-02 00:33
I am but one man. I have read this true Editorial by a staff reporter, Jon Lee Anderson of The New Yorker.

Time is getting short. In 2 short Months we will be asked to elect mid term representatives . We all must now try to reverse the false reports and images that have been presented by The Republicans and their Multi Billion dollar benefactors.

Because of a propaganda technique and lots of money behind them the republican strategists have been able to turn Barack Obama into the Bad Guy in the minds of far too many American voters.

It is my fear that Lies, deceit and politics will blur the memories of the last 8 years of the G.W.Bush Presidency. We MUST overcome the wealth of the propaganda machine that spouts untruths and attempts to blame all of these years of incompetency on our President who is stymied by the "Just say NO" party of the Republicans.

e-mail articles such as this every day to your friends.
 
 
-16 # Guest 2010-09-02 07:37
TO: George Pool. You're kidding, right? "Republicans and their Multi Billion dollar benefactors". Give me a break!

Nothing compares to the massive power of Network News (ABC, CBS, NBC, CNN) who all support Obama. FOX is dwarfed by them.

Almost all major newspapers favor Obama.

The real multi-billion $ donors support Dem’s, not GOP. 9 of the top 10 donors give disproportionat ely to Dem's. The 10th gives to both. Wall Street has for years donated strongly in favor of Dem's. Same with corporate America. Same with Hollywood. Same with trial lawyers. But, the largest political donors of all are the unions who give ALL their $$ to Dem’s.

So, who are you kidding? Obviously, yourself.
 
 
+10 # Guest 2010-09-02 00:39
“Assassin,” “Carnage,” “Cold Steel,” “Crazy Train,” “Rebel,” and “Got Oil?”

I believe this is the sum of the entire article. Such soldiers have not there for any reason but for the enjoyment of wreaking havoc, rather than to attempt dispel it. This is how they have been taught.

That's the sad result of the war machine upon so many, which is why soldiers were signing up for two, three, or more tours, to fuel yet another adrenalin-filled experience.

Do you believe that humans keep their humanity, having being exposed to blood and guts day after day, as a matter of routine, throughout their tours?

American sacrifice versus Iraqi? Twenty-five to one is a conjured number to make things look better for the US.

More than a hundred thousand Iraqis have been slaughtered in this war and several times that number have fled their country too, so as to escape the likes of “Assassin,” “Carnage,” “Cold Steel,” “Crazy Train,” “Rebel,” and “Got Oil?”
 
 
+10 # Guest 2010-09-02 00:57
I too remember the horror of all the looting. The museum, that housed irreplaceable treasures from ancient time, lost much of it's inventory. Really a world treasure, since the "land between the rivers" is where some of the earliest civilized writing is found.

Also can you imagine if looters here destroyed the ministerium of the interior, or where all the records of who owns what is kept. What a nightmare.

I was so furious at all the destruction of a city we were "liberating" and I was deeply ashamed.

I remember too, Rumsfeld saying that stuff happens. What happened was criminal and in my opinion, along with Abu Ghraib, will always be a shame America can not wash away.
 
 
+8 # Guest 2010-09-02 01:03
Bush was warned that the infrastructure was extremely fragile and an invasion would completely destroy it.

The water supply is now in shambles and under Saddam they HAD electricity. Now the poor people of Baghdad have 120 degrees in the summer and about one hour of electricity. Liberation sure is not all it is cracked up to be
 
 
-25 # Guest 2010-09-02 02:13
We were obeying orders that came from the highest ranking officers, which in turn came from a high ranking official, which in turn came from the president, whose orders had a "bleeding heart" filter on because you hippies cant handle the realities of war. Had we more flexibility, perhaps we could have stopped the looters.

Vote red next time, some of us actually still love our country.
 
 
+10 # Guest 2010-09-02 07:25
Quoting
Vote red next time, some of us actually still love our country.

SPC,What does loving your country have to do with the destruction of another one and hundreds of thousands of its people? Do you have a brain?Use it. Was the U.S. in the "right", propelled by "people who love our country" when they lied and deliberately started the Mexican War of 1846-48? The subterfuge of the sinking of the Maine to begin the Spanish_America n War. Industrialists entreaties to get us into WW1? "Domino theory" bulls**t for Korea and Vietnam? How about the 146 treaties signed with native Americans. We didn't honor ONE? Pick up some history books son.Read them!
 
 
+8 # Guest 2010-09-02 07:33
Its this kind of hubris and patriotism that motivated SS Gestapo and the War Criminals and destroyed the honor of decent Germans. It has taken half a century to recover from "following orders". Shame on your thinking. You can love your country by NOT having it run by Imperialist Lying Warmongers!
 
 
+3 # Guest 2010-09-02 11:36
Hi SPC Nunya. I agree that the higher-ranking officers and most probably the rather not-too-bright civilians in that Administration were responsible for the lack of a plan once Baghdad fell. It was not the place of the rank-and-file soldiers to make those sorts of decisions. The buck, however, famously was always passed when it came to the architects of that war. However, a minor point is that the names on the guns were the choice of the individual soldiers, and their own sense of patriotism and heroism should have kept them from writing those names that had anything but 'liberation' in their message. Too bad, because as awful as the realities of war are, many soldiers enlisted and chose to go because of feelings not represented by those words and that inaction in the face of chaos.
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-09-03 20:59
SPC NUNYA, your ignorance is dreadful. Evidently you never heard of WWII and the trial of Nazi war criminals at Nuremburg after the war. You are apparently unaware that "just following orders" was deemed so inexcusable an excuse that some who gave this excuse were executed. You apparently are unaware that our attack on Iraq was just as wrong as Hitler's attack on Poland and the other countries he attempted to take over and that certain members of our prior administration are at risk of being arrested for war crimes should they make the mistake of traveling to certain European destinations. The looters in question would not have been a problem if we had not illegally invaded Iraq in the first place and thanks to our criminal behavior Iraq is worse off now than it would have been if Hussein had been left in power. Sure, this FACT grates on many peoples nerves but I defy you or anyone to demonstrate any way that the world is a better place because we invaded Iraq. Don't even waste your time trying.
 
 
+8 # Guest 2010-09-02 02:34
I'm not an american, so my perspective about the invasion of Iraq might be different. I opposed the invasion in 2003 (as many around the world did, including, as I expected, americans that didn't embarqued in the bandwagon of Bush and Blair) because, among other reasons, it was sold on false premises (how is it possible to fool so many people?), it was a dispersion of resources in the battle against the new forms of terrorism that September 11 showed us, and because it divided what could have been a united front. Obama's promise to withdraw from Iraq is (partially) fulfilled, but I think he should have distanced from Bush, although honoring the troops and the families of the nearly 4.500 american victims, not to mention the iraqi victims.
 
 
+10 # mollie 2010-09-02 03:21
An invading army concerned about the welfare of the nation it is invading, does not allow chaos.
 
 
+11 # Guest 2010-09-02 04:39
According to Geneva Conventions, an invading army is responsible for keeping order and safeguarding the populace. Let's face it, the US is a rogue state.
 
 
+5 # Guest 2010-09-02 08:19
Yes, we are a rogue state and it has been proved that the looters and rioters were brought in by the US to DESTROY THE CULTURE OF IRAQ. And they have continues to do so. This includes setting up a capitalist society privatizing government services, being sure it has a "free market" so the US and its partners can take over the country economically. Early on one diplomat or military person said that a WalMart could take over the country. We are a rogue state and the Joint chiefs and CIA and radical right are in charge.
 
 
+1 # Guest 2010-09-02 04:56
The point is The US did not get the oil contracts. The Europeans and BP did, is there something wrong with this picture?
 
 
+5 # Guest 2010-09-02 08:14
Exxon/Mobil is one of the corps which got an oil contract and US Ambassador Christopher Hill recently called a meeting of all the corps getting contracts for the oil to help them with visas for the workers they will bring into the country where nearly 70% are unemployed!!! This is what winning the war looks like -- for a very few!
 
 
+9 # Guest 2010-09-02 06:54
I am astonished how some people can realy step on the values of the human race, & try to defend The Bush/Blair war on Iraq,a crime against humanity by any standard,desolv ing the army & cnostitusion, leaving the lives & wellfare of 25 million people to the greed of the Iraqi & american & others wolves & vultures. If US & UK are not militarily strong, Bush& Blair would have been to international criminal court lon time ago.
 
 
+8 # Guest 2010-09-02 07:13
Americans love war and if their is no war the corporations wont be happy !
 
 
-16 # Guest 2010-09-02 07:46
SADDAM DID HAVE A WMD PROGRAM. If Saddam were in power today, Iraq and Iran would be locked in a deadly nuclear arms race.

You don't believe me? Goggle "550 tons yellow cake Iraq". You'll get over 54,000 results including from all the major news outlets about how Saddam had enough yellow cake to make plenty of nuke bombs.
 
 
+8 # Guest 2010-09-02 08:02
Well, Tommy, if that had actually been the reason for the U.S. attacking that country, that already debilitated country, folks might be alarmed. Of course, having materials and being able to construct a bomb are two different issues here. Also, there must be a delivery system.

Most of what Hussein had at his command was long gone by the time George W. was put into office, which, by the way, the U.S. government provided. The CIA, surveillance, spy satellites, not to mention Clinton and George H.W. bombing parts of Iraq, pretty much kept Hussein under wraps and his citizens dead and dying.

But - the neo-cons did not attack for that reason, as we all now know. It was merely their first excuse.
 
 
+3 # Guest 2010-09-02 22:25
Google "Obama not US citizen" and you will also come up with a load of equally stupid, indelible internet footprints. It's a wonderful place for the gullible, or those wishing to mislead others, to support petty arguments with absolute misinformation.
 
 
+12 # Guest 2010-09-02 08:29
One last thing: Al Qaeda was NOT in Iraq until the overthrow of Saddam in 2003. Killing Arabs and trshing Arab countries CREATES members of the Taliban and Al Qaeda. Think Afghanistan and how the Taliban base of warriors has grown since the US attacked that country. I think that if we leave that country, number of Taliban will decline -- or, once again, we have set the stage for them to take over the country. Afghanistan can't win for losing.
 
 
+2 # Guest 2010-09-02 10:55
Ok, Afghans and Pakistanis are not arabs but actually they are indo-european language speakers like the Kurds and Iranians. Second, The Taliban was created by the US, literally funded by US taxpayer dollars to maufacture madresseh (schools) to make radical islam fighters. This happened during the proxy war the US fought against the Russians. Taliban means Students (Talib = book).Third, Al Qaida is a US creation. It is called a boogie man. I personally don't care about Al Qaida and Taliban numbers. I care that US leave now and if they don't then they deserve what happens to them.
 
 
-4 # Guest 2010-09-02 10:47
he hopes. he says... such mindlessness
 
 
+4 # Guest 2010-09-02 12:57
Tommy. if we do wars on assumptions like yours, then there will not be world to live in, the fact is US & UK destroyed & looted a country where all the civilizations we know passed in it, reducing it to the stone age, do you justify that? how can you?
 
 
+1 # Guest 2010-09-05 09:01
A close investigation will show Bush giving four (4) reasons for invading Iraq.

None of them pass the smell test.

War crimes trials?

Don't think you will see Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld etc, etc visiting Europe anytime soon.
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.