Share
Email This Page
add comment
Print

Intro: "I'm not against mining. I am against putting mega-mines where they don't belong. Near my home in Utah, Rio Tinto's massive Bingham Canyon Mine is one of the biggest man-made excavations on Earth and has rendered a large area of local groundwater too polluted for human consumption."

Bingham Canyon Mine. (photo: Allen Macbean/Utah by Air)
Bingham Canyon Mine. (photo: Allen Macbean/Utah by Air)



Oppose Bristol Bay Mines

By Robert Redford, Reader Supported News

21 April 11

 

As Companies Gather for Shareholder Meetings, Opposition to Bristol Bay Mine Mounts

'm not against mining. I am against putting mega-mines where they don't belong. Near my home in Utah, Rio Tinto's massive Bingham Canyon Mine is one of the biggest man-made excavations on Earth and has rendered a large area of local groundwater too polluted for human consumption.

Now, the Rio Tinto and Anglo American companies want to put a mine even bigger than Bingham at the headwaters of our planet's greatest wild salmon river systems in Bristol Bay, Alaska. It's an environmental tragedy waiting to happen.

Their Pebble Mine would be gouged out of an American paradise - filled with salmon, bears, moose, caribou, wolves and whales - that has sustained Native communities for thousands of years.

Imagine a pit two miles wide by 2,000 feet deep, and an underground mine a mile deep. This gargantuan gold and copper operation would produce an estimated 10 billion tons of contaminated waste - 3,000 pounds for every man, woman and child on Earth.

Massive earthen dams - some taller than the Three Gorges Dam in China - would be constructed to hold back that waste forever. Now imagine all this in an active earthquake zone at the headwaters of the largest sockeye salmon runs in the world. The threat to Bristol Bay just below is unimaginable.

No wonder the Pebble Mine is opposed by nearly 80 percent of Bristol Bay residents. The growing coalition to stop this disaster-in-the-making is led by Native village corporations, associations and tribes from around Bristol Bay. They've partnered with commercial and recreational fishermen, sportsmen and conservation groups to protect the thousands of jobs and hundreds of millions of dollars that come from Bristol Bay's renewable economic engine: wild salmon.

Anglo American's history is littered with one pollution disaster after another: from Zimbabwe to Ireland to Nevada. Rio Tinto has left a trail of toxic contamination that spans the globe: from Indonesia to Bolivia to Utah. Do you trust these companies to take a catastrophic risk with one of our last and greatest wild places?

In February, the Mitsubishi Corporation did the right thing by ending its participation in this misguided venture.

Now it's time for Rio Tinto and Anglo American to do the same. Both companies are holding their annual shareholder meetings this month in London. In honor of Earth Day, click here to tell these companies that you oppose their plans to industrialize Bristol Bay.

 

Comments  

We are concerned about a recent drift towards vitriol in the RSN Reader comments section. There is a fine line between moderation and censorship. No one likes a harsh or confrontational forum atmosphere. At the same time everyone wants to be able to express themselves freely. We'll start by encouraging good judgment. If that doesn't work we'll have to ramp up the moderation.

General guidelines: Avoid personal attacks on other forum members; Avoid remarks that are ethnically derogatory; Do not advocate violence, or any illegal activity.

Remember that making the world better begins with responsible action.

- The RSN Team

 
+3 # Monty Gee 2011-04-21 22:08
Open cast mining anywhere is a prescription for ecological devastation exactly as it is beneficial to the cost-efficiency of mining. It is time people began to take a long view of the relative environmental costs of open cast mining and the old underground systems, and opted for a step backward in mining technology which would be two steps forward in the earth's survival as a habitat for all living creatures.
 
 
+6 # sharag 2011-04-21 22:24
The Pebble mine must be stopped. Rio Tinto is everywhere. I live and work in Mongolia. Rio Tinto is here, along with their big conservation NGO lackeys. Disrupting local communities, destroying the environment and basically robbing the country of it's mineral resources.

Like Mr. Redford, I'm not against mining, but not at the expense of whole communities and the very environment that sustains us.
 
 
+6 # Nancy Wasser 2011-04-21 22:28
Please do not even think of opening a mine at the headwaters of the greatest wild salmon river in the world.Do you care for nothing but profits?
 
 
-5 # ImaLouiseWright 2011-04-22 03:07
i'm NOT going to oppose this mining operation. americans want to protect their own land, but dont have a problem with destroying other people's lands and killing thousands of people to get their minerals. youre perfectly happy to take over and destroy the lives of everyone in afghanistan, but cry 'not in my back yard'. if you need to wantonly waste all the treasures in the ground, then do it in your own country and stop killing others to take their resources.
 
 
+6 # sark 2011-04-22 06:17
As a USA citizen that has taken action to protect people and their environments all over the world, please know that I am not at all "perfectly happy" with the destruction and killing.
I also watch what I consume to try and make sure what I buy does not contribute to the horrible destruction. It is difficult to do, face it, I am using a computer right now. Almost everything in our consumer driven economy has some connection to a destructive force. For me that means almost daily letter writing and/or making calls to speak out about and calling for the halting of the destruction. That includes war as well as mining, drilling, logging, damn building, polluting energy producers, large agriculture farm businesses and the list goes on. I think there is some type of pro-people and environmental action to be taken in almost if not every country on this planet. So, it is your right to not oppose this mine but it is also my right to inform you that I'd like you to examine your reason for doing so.
Peace,
Sark
 
 
+3 # ImaLouiseWright 2011-04-22 11:00
sark-thanks 4 responding 2 my pique of temper with such a polite response. i know that the environment is a vital issue, & i'm glad that people work 2 protect it. i guess everybody has issues [workers' rights, health care, immigration-2 name a few] that fire them up. the usa policy in the ME, the undermining of america's principles esp.since the 'war on terror', the usa gov's secrecy & lying, the media's intentionally twisting of information 2 mislead people...are things that drive me nuts. it's just that when we say that 'we cant dig HERE', we dont ask ourselves where we are going 2 get the resources that we so cavalierly squander. from what i've read, it seems 2 me that the 'war on terror' is motivated mainly 2 take by force resources from other countries. & 2 do that, we had 2 demonize the people who live there by severely limiting our understanding of them. so when people talk about saving a place of natural beauty filled with wild life in the usa, everything inside me boils over. what about the 1000000s of innocent people, mostly children, who are having their bodies bombed into shreds of skin stuck 2 a rock, their homes converted 2 dust, freezing in refugee camps, dying of malnutrition or infections from their wounded stumps of limbs or missing eyes? yes, save the environment-but 1st we have 2 stop killing ppl to fulill our own greedy overuse of resources.
 
 
+3 # sark 2011-04-22 05:54
Mr. Redford, I contribute to NRDC and participate in all their actions including this one.
Thanks to you and them for all you do.
When NRDC first sent out the email alert asking for donations to get your message aired, I thought about how I wish you would address election integrity. I think that if our votes are actually counted as cast, then we would be heard in all our efforts for environmental, social and economic justice.
Please check out Election Defense Alliance, Mark Crispin Miller, Bradblog and Velvet Revolution to learn more about election integrity, please.
Again, thank you for all you do and for lending your voice to this cause.
Peace,
Sark
 
 
+2 # Digiroo2 2011-04-22 06:15
An open mine at the headwaters of a wild salmon river would be devastating, not to mention the destruction and wider circle of toxicity.
 
 
+6 # Kayjay 2011-04-22 10:49
Today is Earth Day. We all might want to Google 1970 to see how little progress we have made in achieving dreams of the first Earth Day. We must voice a LOUD no to this mining fiasco and its destruction of the wilderness.
 
 
+5 # Joel Atkins 2011-04-22 12:46
The health of the People and our planet must come first!
 
 
+1 # john garot 2011-04-24 06:02
I agree with Redford, ENOUGH IS ENOUGH, let the land flourish on its own! Let not MAN destroy what has been given to us FREELY AND with ABSOLUTE LOVE!!!!
 

THE NEW STREAMLINED RSN LOGIN PROCESS: Register once, then login and you are ready to comment. All you need is a Username and a Password of your choosing and you are free to comment whenever you like! Welcome to the Reader Supported News community.